January 26, 2012

FW: USDA scientist reveals hazards of glyphosate

EcoFarm Logo

Genetic Engineering News List

NOTE: See also 'Dr. Mercola Interviews Dr. Huber about GMO':
Title : USDA Scientist Reveals Hazards of Glyphosate
Date : 20 January 2012

ISIS Report 09/01/12
USDA Scientist Reveals All
Glyphosate Hazards to Crops, Soils, Animals, and Consumers
Don Huber painted a devastating picture of glyphosate and GM crops at UK
Parliament. By Dr Eva Sirinathsinghji
A fully illustrated and referenced version of this report is posted on the
Institute of Science in Society website (http://www.i-sis.org.uk)
In less than an hour, Don Huber, professor emeritus at Purdue University and
USDA senior scientist (see Box) delivered to the UK Houses of Parliament a
damning indictment of glyphosate agriculture as a most serious threat to the
environment, livestock, and human health [1].
Don Huber
Don Huber, Emeritus Professor at Purdue University and senior scientist on
USDA's National Plant Disease Recovery System, has been a plant physiologist and
pathologist for over 40 years. His academic career began with 8 years as a
cereal pathologist at the University of Idaho, and the next 35 years at Purdue
University where he specialised in soil-borne disease control, physiology of
disease, and microbial ecology. For the past 20 years, he has conducted
extensive research into the effects of glyphosate on crops, in response to the
increase in crop diseases on glyphosate-applied fields.
Since his letter to the US Secretary of State Tom Vilsak was leaked in February
2011, there has been a great deal of controversy over what Huber described as a
pathogen "new to science" and abundant in glyphosate-tolerant GM crops (see [2]
Emergency! Pathogen New to Science Found in Roundup Ready GM Crops?, SiS 50). As
he concluded in the letter:

"We are now seeing an unprecedented trend of increasing plant and animal
diseases and disorders. This pathogen may be instrumental to understanding and
solving this problem".
His talk linked glyphosate to reduced nutrient availability in plants,
increasing plant diseases, the emergence of a new pathogen, animal illness and
possible effects on human health (see [3, 4] Glyphosate Tolerant Crops Bring
Death and Disease, Scientists Reveal Glyphosate Poisons Crops and Soil, SiS 47).
Pathogen new to science
The conversion of US agriculture to monochemical herbicide practice has resulted
in the extensive use of glyphosate herbicides. Coincidentally, farmers have been
witnessing deterioration in the health of corn, soybean, wheat and other crops,
and epidemics of diseases in small grain crops. All are associated with the
extensive use of glyphosate, which has increased further since the introduction
of glyphosate-tolerant, Roundup Ready (RR) crops.
Glyphosate immobilises nutrients required to maintain plant health and
resistance to disease. This weakening of the plants defence could explain the
infestation of GM crops with the new pathogen, which has now been observed in
horse, sheep, pigs, cows, chicken, multiple animal tissues including
reproductive parts (semen, amniotic fluid), manure, soil, eggs, milk, as well as
the common fungal pathogen that is currently infesting RR crops, Fusarium solani
fsp glycines mycelium. All are coming into contact with glyphosate either
through direct exposure or consumption through animal feed. It is also highly
abundant in crops suffering from plant Goss' wilt and sudden death syndrome.
The pathogen can be cultured in the lab, and has been isolated from livestock
foetal tissue, replicated in the lab and re-introduced back into the animals. It
appears to be very common and may well be interacting with the effects of
glyphosate on both plants and animals, exacerbating disease and causing
reproductive failure in livestock (see below). Although great expectations have
been placed on Huber to publish his findings, he insists that before this can be
done, further resources are necessary to be able to characterise the 'entity'
and identify what type of species it is, including sequencing of its genome.
This is a slow process and once complete, it is his intention to publish the
work in a peer-reviewed journal.
Understanding glyphosate's mode of action
Recognising glyphosate's mechanism of action is the key to understanding how it
may exert detrimental effects on the health of crops, animals, and the
environment alike. Glyphosate is a broad-spectrum herbicide that interacts with
a range of physiological processes in the plant and its environment. Although it
is most commonly recognised to work through inhibition of the plant enzyme
5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase (EPSPS) involved in the production
of aromatic amino acids in the shikimate pathway, it was actually first patented
as a strong metal-chelator that binds to metals including manganese, magnesium,
iron, nickel, zinc and calcium, many of which are important micronutrients
acting as co-factors for plant enzymes in different physiological processes
including the plants' defence system. Indeed, it is actually through chelation
of manganese that the EPSPS enzyme is inhibited.
Rendering plants more susceptible to disease through glyphosate's pathogenic
activity is actually the way it exerts its herbicidal activity.
This is done not just through immobilising nutrients in the plant but also
impacting the agricultural system as a whole. Consistently, if glyphosate does
not reach the root of a plant or the plant is grown in a sterile soil, the plant
is not killed.
Once in the soil, glyphosate is later immobilised through the chelation of
cations, and is therefore very stable and not easily degraded. However,
phosphorus (including phosphorus fertilisers) can desorb the herbicide, making
it active once again in the soil.
Glyphosate interferes negatively with many components of agriculture Huber
stressed that agriculture is an integrated system of many interacting
components, which together determine crop health and therefore yield. This
concept is undervalued, and the sooner this is recognised, the sooner we will be
able to reap the full genetic potential of our crops.
The three main components of an agricultural system are 1) the biotic
environment including beneficial organisms for example, nitrogen-fixing microbes
and mineralizers; 2) the abiotic environment including nutrients, moisture, pH;
and 3), defence against pathogens that damage crops. The genetic potential of a
plant can be achieved by minimising the stress placed on these components
through improving plant nutrition and physiology and prevention of diseases and
We have been repeatedly told that to meet the world's needs for food production
we must resort to GM crops and chemical agriculture. However, glyphosate
detrimentally interacts with all the agricultural components, so much so that an
estimated 50 percent of the potential crop yields are currently being lost (see
Figure 1).
As shown in figure 1, glyphosate interacts with a wide range of health
determinants, which intensifies stress and reduces crop yields. Not only does it
accumulate in the plant tissues (shoot and root tips, reproductive structures
and legume nodules), it accumulates in the roots where it then leaks into the
soil and harms beneficial microorganisms in the soil including those that act as
biological controls of pathogens. The obvious consequence is the increased
virulence of soil-borne pathogens that lead to disease.
Glyphosate immobilises nutrients critical for plant defence system and other
One of Huber's important discoveries was the close correlation of all the known
conditions affecting the disease 'take-all' with the availability of manganese
to the plant and its physiological effect on resistance to this pathogen.
Micronutrients are the activators or inhibitors of many critical physiological
functions. Thus, a deficiency or change in availability of these regulatory
elements can greatly affect plant growth and resistance to diseases and pests.
Those metabolic pathways producing secondary anti-microbial compounds,
pathogen-inhibiting amino acids and peptides, hormones involved in cicatrisation
(walling off pathogens), callusing, and disease escape mechanisms can all be
compromised by glyphosate.
Micronutrients are also necessary for other processes in a plant.
Manganese for example is not only involved in co-activating the EPSPS enzyme,
with up to 25 other enzymes known to be affected by manganese chelation. Such
enzymes are necessary for photosynthesis, in assimilating carbon dioxide in the
electron transport chain, along with zinc. It also helps in the synthesis of
chlorophyll and in nitrate assimilation.
Numerous enzymes requiring other mineral co-factors are also affected, among
them enzymes of the shikimate pathway, to which EPSPS belongs, are responsible
for plant responses to stress and the synthesis of defence molecules against
pathogens, such as amino acids, lignins, hormones, phytoalexins, flavenoids and
Consistent with what is known about the role of micronutrients and glyphosate,
the levels of key minerals have been measured in transgenic RR soybeans and
found to be lower than those in isogenic non-transgenic varieties. Manganese was
reduced by as much as 45 %, while iron was reduced by 49 % [5]. Similar
deficiencies in mineral content have been found in non-GM varieties, suggesting
that the glyphosate, and not the RR transgene, is responsible for reducing
mineral availability [6].
Glyphosate reduces photosynthesis, water uptake, amino acid production as well
as lignin, a molecule conferring mechanical strength of the plant and crucial
for conducting water through plant stems [7, 8].
As Huber stated, the consequences of these nutrient deficiencies is that "crops
don't look as good, are not as productive or rigorous, and are slower growing"
(see Figure 2). He noted yield drags of 26 % for RR soybeans. Furthermore, with
current concerns for global warming, plants that are up to 50 % less
water-efficient, such as RR crops, are counter-productive and can only
exacerbate problems.
Huber stressed that there is nothing in the glyphosate tolerant crops that
operates on the glyphosate applied to them. Consequently, although they have
enough resistance to prevent them from dying (conferred by the EPSPS transgene),
their overall physiological function is compromised by glyphosate. It therefore
affects GM as well as non-GM crops through residual levels of glyphosate in the
In addition to chelating nutrients in the plants, glyphosate can lower mineral
content through damaging beneficial soil organisms, including microbes producing
indole-acetic acid (a growth-promoting auxin), earthworms, mycorrhizae
associations, phosphorus & zinc uptake, microbes such as Pseudomonads, Bacillus
that convert insoluble soil oxides to plant-available forms of manganese and
iron, nitrogen-fixing bacteria Bradyrhizobium, Rhizobium, and organisms involved
in the biological control of soil-borne diseases that reduce root uptake of
Figure 2 Effects of long-term glyphosate on crop health; adapted from
Huber's presentation
Glyphosate increases incidence and virulence of soil-borne pathogens Thirty-four
diseases have been reported in the scientific literature to increase in
incidence as a result of glyphosate weed-eradication programmes. They affect a
wide variety of crops from cereals to bananas, tomatoes, soybean, cotton,
canola, melon and grapes [9]. Some of these diseases are considered 'emerging'
or 're-emerging' as they had not caused serious economic losses in the past.
This has worrying implications for the agricultural sector with the US now in
its fourth year of epidemics of Goss' wilt and sudden death syndrome and
eighteenth year of epidemic of Fusarium fungal colonisation resulting in root
rot and Fusarium wilt. Not only does glyphosate affect disease susceptibility,
there is also evidence of increased disease severity. Examples include
'take-all'; Corynespora root rot in soybean; Fusarium spp diseases, including
those caused by Fusarium species that are ordinarily non-pathogenic.
Head-scab caused by Fusarium spp of cereals increases following glyphosate
application, which is also now prevalent in cooler climates when previously it
was limited to warmer climates.
Food and Feed Safety Concerns
Nutrient-deficient, transgenic plants suffering from disease that also harbour
herbicide residues, presents an array of possible safety hazards to animals and
humans. According to Huber, possible harm include direct toxicity of glyphosate
itself, which has been shown to cause endocrine disruption, DNA damage,
reproductive and developmental toxicities, neurotoxicity, cancer, and birth
defects (see [10]Glyphosate Toxic and Roundup Worse,SiS26; [11]Death by Multiple
Poisoning, Glyphosate and Roundup,SiS42; [12]Ban Glyphosate HerbicideNow.SiS43;
[13]Lab Study Establishes Glyphosate Link to Birth Defects,SiS48). Furthermore,
allergies are on the rise, and animals are showing allergy responses, including
inflamed irritated stomachs (Figure 3), discoloration of stomach lining, leakage
of intestines as well as behavioural symptoms of irritability and anti-social
behaviour in cows (abnormal for herd animals). Inflammatory bowel disease in
humans has risen 40 percent since 1992, which may be
related to consumption of GM foods, although this has not yet been proven.
The increase in infestation of crops with fungal pathogens that produce toxins
is an added concern. Mycotoxins, including fusarium toxins as well as aflatoxins
released by Aspergillus fungi are carcinogenic and have forced imports of wheat
into the US due to unsafe levels found in domestic harvests.
Triple whammy of reproductive toxicity caused by glyphosate In 2002, the
Cattlemen's Association gave a statement to US Congress on the serious and
puzzling rises in reproductive problems. It said: "high numbers of foetuses are
aborting for no apparent reason. Other farmers successfully raise what look to
be normal young cattle, only to learn when the animals are butchered that their
carcasses appear old and, therefore, less valuable...The sporadic problem is so
bad both in the United States and abroad that in some herds around 40-50 percent
of pregnancies are being lost.. [and] the viability of this important industry
is threatened."
Glyphosate appears to be able to induce reproductive failures through three
separate mechanisms. The first, mentioned above is the endocrine dysfunction
caused by direct toxicity of glyphosate.
The second is the reduced nutrient content having consequential effects on the
nutritional status of animals. Manganese in animals, as in plants, is an
essential nutrient, and deficiencies have been associated with a variety of
diseases as well as reproductive failures, which are becoming increasingly
common in livestock. One study performed in Australia following two seasons of
high levels of stillbirths in cattle found that all dead calves were manganese
deficient [14]. Furthermore, 63 percent of babies with birth defects were also
deficient. Manganese is known to be important for mobilising calcium into bones,
correlating with abnormal bone formation in these calves.
Third, the unknown pathogenic 'entity' may be associated with inducing
pseudo-pregnancies. As far back as 1998, a suspect agent was found in
reproductive tissue of livestock. It has now been isolated in high
concentrations from semen, amniotic fluid as well as placental tissue. It has
also been found in aborted foetal tissue. Some farms are reporting up to 50
percent fewer conceptions in animals due to increased miscarriages and
pseudo-pregnancies. Although evidence of the widespread presence of this new
pathogen is clear, Don Huber suggested the need for further research to
understand not only what kind of pathogen it is, but importantly, the effects it
is having on the health of plants as well as animals.
To conclude
Over 100 peer reviewed papers have been published by Huber and other scientists
on the detrimental effects of glyphosate. Glyphosate increases disease in plants
(as well as animals), prompting Huber to write to the Secretary of Agriculture.
It may be linked to many health problems in animals and humans, which are an
added cost to all the failed promises of a new agricultural technology that
would feed the world. As Huber concluded, the "public trust has been betrayed."

Website: http://www.gmwatch.org

The Genetic Engineering Blog is produced by Thomas Wittman and EcoFarm, and supported by a generous donation from the Newman's Own Foundation.  Please pass this vital information on.  If you would like to get on this list go to www.eco-farm.org and select Blogs.

Follow us on Twitter

Find us on Facebook

No comments:

Post a Comment

Cuatro Caminos Calendar